Call Us 866.940.1101 ☰ ˟
866.940.1101
Logo
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Employee Directory
    • Partners Page
    • Event Calendar
    • Refer a Friend
  • Get A Quote
  • Products
    • Lawyers Malpractice Insurance
    • Professional Liability Coverage For Attorneys
    • Accountants Professional Liability
    • Dentist Malpractice Insurance
    • Business Owners Policy
    • Cyber Liability Insurance
    • Workers Compensation Insurance
    • Title Agents E&O Insurance
    • Paralegal Malpractice Insurance
  • Testimonials
  • Common Terms
    • Common Terms
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Areas We Serve
    • Grand Rapids, MI
    • Detroit, MI
    • Lansing, MI
    • Kalamazoo, MI
Home > Blog > Malpractice Insurance—Policy Insurer Breached its Duty to Defend Cannot Invoke Defenses Later
TUESDAY, MAY 23, 2017

Malpractice Insurance—Policy Insurer Breached its Duty to Defend Cannot Invoke Defenses Later

“Duty to Defend” is an important provision in most Professional liability and Malpractice Insurance policies.  This gives the insured the peace of mind that an insurer cannot just choose not to defend without clearly stating why the policy does not provide coverage.  The reason that a “Duty to Defend” policy is purchased is to make sure the insurer is not left high and dry when a claim is reported.  There are consequences for an insurer abandoning an insured with a “Duty to Defend” policy.

In 2008 Title Industry Assurance Company RRG (TIAC) (the Insurer) v First American Title Insurance Company (FATIC) and affiliates (claimants), (the insured) Chicago Abstract Title Agency LLC was sued by FATIC the claimants.    The Insurer TIAC had four choices as to how to respond:

(a) Defend Chicago Abstract with‐ out reservation; or

(b) Defend while reserving its rights; or

(c) Seek a declaratory judgment concerning the scope of coverage. TIAC could also

(d) Decline to defend, but only if the allegations in the complaints against Chicago Abstract clearly fell outside the scope of the insurance policy, and then only at its peril. Under Illinois Law, when a liability insurer unjustifiably refuses to defend a suit against its insured, the insurer will be estopped from later asserting policy defenses to coverage.

TIAC declined to defend the suit.  The years past the insured Chicago Abstract had liquidated and dissolved in 2009.  In 2014, the claimants filed a 4th amended complaint against Chicago Abstract.  TIAC attempted to have a declaratory action in federal court stating there was no coverage because of 2 policy exclusions.   The Federal District Court and now the 7th Circuit ruled against TIAC stating that TIAC breached its duty to defend the insured and is now estopped from asserting policy defenses.  As the Knights Templar stated in Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, TIAC choose poorly.

Posted 12:29 PM

Tags: malpractice insurance, claims, duty to defend
Share |


No Comments


Post a Comment
Required
Required (Not Displayed)
Required


All comments are moderated and stripped of HTML.

NOTICE: This blog and website are made available by the publisher for educational and informational purposes only. It is not be used as a substitute for competent insurance, legal, or tax advice from a licensed professional in your state. By using this blog site you understand that there is no broker client relationship between you and the blog and website publisher.
Blog Archive
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2013
  • 2011

  • lawyers professional liability insurance(429)
  • attorney malpractice insurance(348)
  • attorney malpractice(330)
  • legal malpractice(223)
  • legal liability(134)
  • cyber insurance(94)
  • data breach(92)
  • ethics(87)
  • erp(56)
  • malpractice insurance(49)
  • claims(39)
  • title agency e&o(36)
  • accountant e&o(34)
  • extended reporting period endorsement(30)
  • tail(29)
  • phishing(25)
  • claims made coverage(20)
  • extended reporting period(20)
  • prior acts(19)
  • legal malpractice insurance(18)
  • cyber liability(18)
  • cyber security(17)
  • accountant errors & omissions(17)
  • claims reporting(17)
  • ransomware(16)
  • claim prevention(16)
  • crime insurance(15)
  • attorney protective cle(14)
  • the hartford weekly newsletter(14)
  • mcgowan webinar series for cpas 2021(12)
  • professional liability insurance(12)
  • attorney protective cle webinar(12)
  • business owners insurance(11)
  • legal liability insurance(11)
  • fee suits(10)
  • retirement tail(10)
  • full prior acts(10)
  • bop(9)
  • title agent errors & omissions(9)
  • cyber crime(9)
  • accountant errors & omissions insurance(9)
  • prior acts date(8)
  • webinar(8)
  • non-practicing erp(8)
  • cyber liability insurance(8)
  • lawyers(8)
  • claims made(8)
  • employment practices liability(7)
  • attorney protective 2019 free cle webinar(7)
  • non-practicing extended reporting period endorsement(7)

View Mobile Version
Logo
Quick Links
Home Our Products Customer Service Payment Options Common Terms
About Us Refer A Friend Our Carriers Blog Contact Us
Location
2430 Camelot Ct SE
Grand Rapids, MI 49546

Local: 616.940.1101
Toll Free: 866.940.1101
Email: info@L2ins.com
Facebook Twitter Social LinkedIn
© Copyright. All rights reserved.
Powered by Insurance Website Builder