AI Hallucinations in Legal Briefs: A Growing Insurance Risk for Law Firms
Artificial intelligence is transforming legal practice, but AI-generated hallucinations are creating significant professional liability risks for law firms. Courts across the country have made it clear that attorneys remain responsible for every citation, quotation, and legal argument filed with the court even when AI assists with drafting. [yahoo.com], [cbsnews.com]
Recent matters involving Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani highlight the consequences of failing to verify AI-generated content before filing.
Recent Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP AI Hallucination Matters
-
-
- Strike 1 – Jackson Hospital & Clinic Bankruptcy Matter – An Alabama bankruptcy court criticized a Gordon Rees filing for containing inaccurate and fabricated legal authorities, leading to court scrutiny and significant reputational consequences for the firm. [abovethelaw.com], [vibegraveyard.ai]
- Strike 2 – Villalovos-Gutierrez v. Pol – In December 2025, a federal magistrate judge warned Gordon Rees against filing documents containing AI-hallucinated or fictitious legal citations and noted that failure to verify AI-generated authorities could be grounds for sanctions. [completeai…aining.com], [elawnj.com]
- Strike 3 – Huynh v. Redis Labs – In 2026, opposing counsel alleged that a Gordon Rees brief contained inaccurate or unsupported descriptions of legal authorities, underscoring the heightened scrutiny firms face following prior AI-related incidents. [abovethelaw.com], [completeai…aining.com]
-
The Insurance Problem
AI hallucinations can expose law firms to:
-
-
- Court sanctions
- Attorney-fee awards
- Increased malpractice exposure
- Reputational damage
- Bar complaints and disciplinary investigations
-
Lawyers Professional Liability (LPL) policies typically exclude court-imposed sanctions, penalties, and attorney-fee awards, meaning firms may have to absorb those costs directly even when malpractice coverage exists for other claims. Coverage varies by policy and jurisdiction. [l2insuranc…agency.com], [claimsjournal.com]
How Law Firms Can Reduce AI Liability Risk
The most effective defense is a documented AI governance program:
-
-
- Verify every citation against the original source.
- Require attorney review of all AI-assisted filings.
- Prohibit blind reliance on AI-generated case law.
- Maintain written AI-use policies.
- Implement mandatory citation-checking procedures.
- Train attorneys on AI risks and professional responsibility obligations.
-
Bottom Line
AI can improve efficiency, but it cannot replace a lawyer’s duty of competence. The recent Gordon Rees matters demonstrates that a single hallucinated citation can lead to sanctions, reputational harm, and potentially uninsured losses. But after three strikes not sure what the final punishment will be. For law firms, strong AI controls and citation verification procedures are no longer optional; they are an essential part of risk management and professional liability protection. [vibegraveyard.ai], [completeai…aining.com], [yahoo.com]
Request a Legal Malpractice Quote
Contact Me Today
Lee Norcross, MBA, CPCU
California License # 0D87292
L Squared Insurance Agency, LLC ® DBA in California as L2 L Squared Insurance Agency, License # 0L93416
Managing Director, CEO
Lee@L2Ins.com
616-726-7080
